I saw Leap of Faith last night on Broadway. Now, they did change a few things from the Ahmanson in LA (at least as I can tell from the You Tube stuff). The biggest seems to be the Love Interest was a Waitress and now she is the Sherif - which really works well.
I am going to review it, but - spoiler alert - I loved it. The cast, not just Raul Esparza - but especially him - take a pretty good show and make it amazing.